In their urgent book, “Science Under Siege,” scientists Michael Mann and Peter Hotez argue that anti-science forces, driven by far-right political movements, pose a dire threat to humanity’s future. Using a dramatic narrative, they describe this as a battle for Earth, akin to themes in “The Lord of the Rings,” against a movement that weaponizes anti-scientific disinformation.
Both authors emphasize the personal costs they’ve faced due to their advocacy, highlighted by persistent threats and attacks. Mann warns that climate change denial, supported by fossil fuel exploitation, risks exceeding critical warming limits. Hotez highlights how misinformation about vaccines undermines public health and pandemic preparedness.
Identifying five key actors in the anti-science movement—plutocrats, petrostates, professionals spreading disinformation, propagandists, and some media outlets—the authors advocate for a comprehensive strategy to engage more scientists in public discourse, protect outspoken individuals, and combat disinformation.
While the book briefly touches on improving science education, it exhibits a political bias by attributing the anti-science threat primarily to the right, overlooking issues from the left, such as resistance to nuclear power and biotechnology.
Despite occasional exaggerations, “Science Under Siege” is recommended for those committed to advocating for a sustainable future.
