The article by Maya Sunderraj critiques the YouTube series “Surrounded” by Jubilee, where one expert debates 20 non-experts on controversial topics. Sunderraj argues that these debates devolve into chaotic verbal battles rather than meaningful discussions, often leading to frustration and skepticism among viewers. The series has featured notable contentious moments, including applause for a guest admitting to fascist beliefs, which raises ethical concerns about providing a platform for such ideologies.
While Jubilee aims to foster conversation and empathy, Sunderraj believes the voting structure among guests limits honest discourse and encourages groupthink, prioritizing entertainment over genuine understanding. The article emphasizes that engaging with individuals supporting harmful ideologies like fascism should be approached with criticism rather than dialogue, reflecting a belief that such viewpoints deserve condemnation rather than a platform.
