John Mitnick, a conservative attorney and one of the architects of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), has expressed deep frustration over the agency’s conduct, labeling it as a “monster.” Following the fatal shooting of nurse Alex Pretti by a federal immigration agent, Mitnick took to social media to condemn DHS for its “lawlessness, fascism, and cruelty,” calling for the impeachment of Trump.
Mitnick has a long history with DHS, having served during its formation and later as general counsel under Trump. He was ousted after opposing a controversial policy to release detained migrants into Democratic-led cities, a move seen as politically motivated by Trump advisor Stephen Miller. Unlike others who regret their association with DHS, Mitnick asserts that the agency’s issues stem from a lack of integrity among current leaders, not the agency’s name itself.
The article details a troubling pattern of behavior by DHS officials following violent incidents, where they attempt to vilify victims instead of ensuring a neutral investigation. Public opinion is turning against the agency, with a recent poll showing a significant number of Americans, including a record percentage of Republicans, now wanting to abolish Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The prevailing sentiment is that, if even a former insider like Mitnick is alarmed by its actions, it underscores the extent of DHS’s deviation from its original mission.

