The article discusses the author’s discomfort as a progressive Christian with the political left’s disproportionate criticism of Christian nationalism compared to Zionism. While acknowledging that Christian nationalism is a threat to pluralistic societies and rooted in white privilege, the author argues that the left often fails to equally condemn Zionism, which emerged in the 19th century as a response to antisemitic persecution, leading to the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
The author details how both forms of nationalism prioritize one religious/ethnic group over others, asserting rights based on historical or divine claims, which can undermine the dignity of non-conforming populations. The rise of Christian nationalism is linked to various harmful social policies and attitudes, while Zionism is criticized for its colonial implications and inherent violence against Palestinians.
Ultimately, the author calls for consistent critique across all forms of religious nationalism, asserting that ignoring such issues in any faith undermines moral integrity. All forms of nationalism should be scrutinized for their potential to strip marginalized groups of rights and dignity.
