Gerald Horne’s article responds to Comrade Bob Wing’s analysis of the U.S. republic, emphasizing that while progress has been made in understanding the nation’s complexities, the U.S. left has lagged behind both the ruling class and moderate African-American perspectives on issues of white supremacy and settler colonialism. Horne cites notable works, including Raoul Peck’s HBO Max series “Exterminate All the Brutes” and Nikole Hannah-Jones’ 1619 Project, as critical examinations of historical narratives that challenge conventional views.
The article critiques the failure of some factions of the left to adequately confront the foundational myths of the U.S., particularly the mythologized 1776 revolution, which often ignores the implications for marginalized groups. Horne discusses the interplay between settler colonialism, the construction of whiteness, and capitalism, arguing that this historical context underpins contemporary political dynamics.
He goes on to criticize what he deems “left-wing white nationalism,” where oppressed groups are coerced into class collaborations that align with descendent oppressors. This misalignment perpetuates a failure to build genuine class unity, especially as seen in voting behaviors.
Horne advocates for forging international alliances beyond U.S. borders that counter the currently prevalent Cold War rhetoric. He emphasizes the need to understand imperialism and white supremacy as fundamental components of social struggle, positing that effective change must confront these issues head-on. He concludes by commending Wing for challenging the radical left to move beyond its current limitations.
